3 Comments
May 27Liked by Shailendra Singh Bisht

This article raises interesting questions about the ethics of AI-generated voice technology. It's great to see the potential for this technology to democratise audio creation and enhance storytelling, but it's important to consider the potential downsides as well. For example, the misuse of this technology for impersonation or manipulation could be a real problem.

The legal case you mentioned regarding Indian movie stars is a fascinating development. It's important to protect the unique traits and expressions of artists, but it's also important to strike a balance so that fair use isn't stifled.

Overall, I think AI voices have the potential to be a powerful tool, but it's important to use them responsibly. We need to make sure that this technology is used to empower creators and enhance content, not to replace human talent.

As an academic interested in AI, I would be interested in learning more about the potential impact of this technology on the entertainment industry. I would also be interested in exploring the legal and ethical issues surrounding AI-generated voices in more detail.

Expand full comment

Your newsletter this week was incredibly insightful and covered a lot of ground. The discussion on AI-generated voices, particularly the ethical implications, was thought-provoking. The contrast between Scarlett Johansson's case and the "Reid-ish" project highlighted the complexities of creative ownership in the digital age. I appreciate how you balanced the opportunities AI presents with the potential challenges, especially regarding creative labor and ethical concerns. The SKYFALL framework applied to NIL was a brilliant touch, offering a clear view of the pros and cons of digital platforms for creative professionals. It’s essential to recognize both the empowerment these platforms offer and the vulnerabilities they introduce, such as fake accounts and copyright issues.

Moreover, your analysis of the Indian legal landscape for personality rights was enlightening. The recent legal protections for celebrities like Amitabh Bachchan and Anil Kapoor are indeed a positive step, though the need for a more robust legal framework is evident. Finally, the update on Hyderabad Runners was inspiring. The community’s growth and the emphasis on core values like Community First and Collaboration are commendable. I’m particularly excited about the Civic Engagement Program for the Hyderabad Marathon, as it promises to enhance community involvement and support for runners.

Thanks for sharing sir. Great read!

Expand full comment

Thank you for sharing this detailed and insightful newsletter. The ethical dilemmas surrounding AI and creative ownership you highlighted are timely and thought-provoking. Scarlett Johansson's case underscores the need for clear guidelines and respectful practices in AI development, especially when it involves replicating human attributes. The "Reid-ish" episode from Masters of Scale offers an exciting glimpse into the future, but it's essential to navigate this space responsibly to protect the interests of artists and creators.

The SKYFALL framework applied to the entertainment industry is a brilliant way to balance opportunities and downsides, emphasizing the importance of safeguarding Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL). This nuanced approach can help creative professionals maximize the benefits of digital platforms while mitigating potential risks.

The reflections on Indian movie stars' personality rights add another layer to the discussion, showing how legal protections can evolve to address new challenges. Your call for a comprehensive personality rights law in India is well-founded, as it would provide much-needed clarity and security for artists.

On a lighter note, congratulations on the 17th anniversary of Hyderabad Runners! The commitment to core values and community engagement is inspiring. The idea of a Civic Engagement Program for the Hyderabad Marathon is fantastic—it not only promotes health and fitness but also fosters a sense of community spirit. I’m looking forward to seeing how this initiative unfolds and contributes to the marathon's success.

Looking forward to your next update!

Expand full comment